Reminded Once Again: Check Magazines & Ammo...

Renown Browning Hi Power Expert - Stephen A. Camp

Moderator: carlson1

Reminded Once Again: Check Magazines & Ammo...

Postby Stephen A. Camp » Sun Feb 07, 2010 12:29 am

Hello. Over the last four decades I have come across defective factory ammunition right out of the box that should have never left the factory. In some instances, primers were seated upside down or completely missing, cases were crushed or the bullets themselves were visually out of spec.

Image
Here are two Federal .45 ACP 230-gr. Hydrashok cartridges. It is pretty obvious that the one on the left is not as Federal intended when it somehow slipped out and was purchased in a box of ammunition. (This picture was taken several years ago and the cartridges shown were not a "rushed production" items. Many will recognize them as Hydrashoks using a truncated cone shaped bullet than the more rounded one used in current Federal Hydrashok ammunition.)

Though certainly not common, I have seen defective factory rounds from practically all manufacturers, not just Federal. While a little unnerving, I guess that when hundreds of thousands (or more) of cartridges are being manufactured, some that shouldn't slip by, do, despite quality-control checks.

My point is not to try and "defame" any reputable ammo makers, only to suggest that it is perhaps a wise thing to check each and every cartridge intended for "serious" use such as home defense or in a carry gun...and in all magazines dedicated for such purposes.

I routinely do this with all ammunition intended for such purposes, be it for rifle, revolver or semiautomatic.

A few weeks ago, I shot my SIG-Sauer P220 DAK, cleaned it upon returning home and locked it away in the safe. A day or two ago, I opted to load it up for home protection as well as for concealed carry for about a month in order to do a follow-up article to one done on the gun a year or two back.

My normal .45 ACP "carry ammo" is usually Remington 230-gr. Golden Saber, Winchester 230-gr. Ranger JHP or Federal Classic 230-gr. JHP (since I have quite a bit of the stuff around.) I usually pick whichever I happen to have enough rounds from an already-opened box to handle 8-shots in the pistol and 7 more in a spare magazine for it. (The current magazines will hold 8; I simply prefer my single-stack .45's to hold the same number of rounds as my 1911's and since I have 7-shot magazines by the score for them...)

Image
When I carry a .45 auto, it is usually loaded with one of these three 230-gr factory JHP's. From left to right: Winchester Ranger, Federal Classic and Remington Golden Saber. Remington's 230-gr. Golden Saber is easy to spot as being slightly longer and usually measures right at 1.23" on average.

I began loading a couple of magazines for my P220 DAK SAS ("SIG Anti-Snag) .45 pistol with Golden Sabers. This round has proven to feed smoothly in all of my 1911-pattern pistols as well as this and my other P220 as well as one I recently sold. The magazines were brand new ones.

The ammunition "jammed" in one of them". LOA for the Golden Sabers was the usual 1.23" on average. I checked the LOA of cartridges from the box these came from against others having a different lot number; both had the same average LOA.

The problem appears to be the length of the cartridge along with the width/shape of the hollow point in some of the current 8-shot SIG-Sauer stainless steel factory magazines. (Not all but some. In my admittedly statistically-invalid case, the figure would be one out of four such magazines or 25%.)

Image
This is the magazine in question. It is marked "SIG SAUER P220-1 45" on the lower left side and "Made in Italy" on the other. (I figure it was manufactured by Mec-Gar, a favorite maker of quality magazines by myself and many others.)

Though it didn't happen all of the time, Golden Saber cartridges would hang up tight and failed to feed when cycled by hand. (Later on the same day, I determined that they failed to feed as well in firing...but ONLY in that one individual magazine.)

Image
Here you can see the "nose-dived" Golden Saber. In this particular instance, it was the last round in the magazine but this stoppage also occurred with differing numbers of cartridges still in the magazine.

Image
Here is a view of the same problem from the top. The "inward curved" front of the magazine (about the 2 o'clock position) does not appear to be a "ding" or other than intended from the manufacturer. My other stainless 8-round P220 factory magazines are the same way and function fine with the same ammunition.

Having said that, I believe that this inward curve to be at the core of this magazine's function-problems with this ammunition. I cannot measure how much it is curved inward compared to other magazines but I suspect that it is very slightly more. I cannot see it visually when comparing this magazine to others of the same line. However, this inward curve is less noticeable in my old blued factory 7-shot magazines...of which all that I've tried so far (10) have worked flawlessly. FWIW, the "problem magazine" worked 100% with:

24 shots using Winchester Ranger 230-gr. JHP
24 shots using Federal 230-gr. Classic JHP
24 shots using Federal 230-gr. Hydrashok (truncated cone)
24 shots using Federal 230-gr. Hydrashok (current style)
24 shots using Hornady 230-gr. TAP (XTP)

My point is not to criticize Remington, SIG-Sauer or Mec-Gar. It is simply to suggest not taking any product's functioning or "dimensional correctness" out of the box for granted. This problem-combination just happened to be the latest I experienced.

Such "unintended consequences" could be aggravating at the least on a range trip or tragic in the extreme in a deadly force situation.

Best.
Stephen A. Camp
 

Re: Reminded Once Again: Check Magazines & Ammo...

Postby MoJo » Sun Feb 07, 2010 12:31 pm

:iagree: Just because it's supposed to work doesn't mean it will. Mr. Murphy is on the job 24-7-365 and he doesn't care who you are he'll make your gear foul up at the worst time. :banghead:

Never assume it'll work. Check, check again, then triple check. :thumbs2:
"To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason
Texas and Louisiana CHL Instructor, NRA Pistol, Rifle, Shotgun, Personal Protection and Refuse To Be A Victim Instructor
User avatar
MoJo
Senior Member
 
Posts: 4871
Joined: Thu Dec 23, 2004 6:10 pm
Location: Vidor, Tx

Re: Reminded Once Again: Check Magazines & Ammo...

Postby WildBill » Sun Feb 07, 2010 1:08 pm

Stephen A. Camp wrote:Hello. Over the last four decades I have come across defective factory ammunition right out of the box that should have never left the factory. In some instances, primers were seated upside down or completely missing, cases were crushed or the bullets themselves were visually out of spec.

My point is not to criticize Remington, SIG-Sauer or Mec-Gar. It is simply to suggest not taking any product's functioning or "dimensional correctness" out of the box for granted. This problem-combination just happened to be the latest I experienced.
The same goes for people who universally criticize handloads.
NRA Life Member
User avatar
WildBill
Senior Member
 
Posts: 13379
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2007 12:53 pm
Location: Houston

Re: Reminded Once Again: Check Magazines & Ammo...

Postby tacticool » Sun Feb 07, 2010 3:44 pm

Thanks for the reminder. Check your gear!
When in doubt
Vote them out!
User avatar
tacticool
Senior Member
 
Posts: 1483
Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 2:41 pm

Re: Reminded Once Again: Check Magazines & Ammo...

Postby gigag04 » Sun Feb 07, 2010 11:44 pm

Any mag in a defense weapon that messes up once in training gets cleaned and inspected. It also gets marked. If it has another blip in any capacity it is crushed and destroyed. Mags are cheap - life is valuable is what I've heard said regarding this topic. This goes for rifles and handguns.
Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work. - Thomas Edison
User avatar
gigag04
Senior Member
 
Posts: 5469
Joined: Wed May 04, 2005 7:47 pm
Location: Houston

Re: Reminded Once Again: Check Magazines & Ammo...

Postby nmsu » Wed Feb 24, 2010 8:22 am

I've seen the nose of the bullet get flattened out after significant time in a magazine AND with the person (in this case security officers) patrolling back desert roads.
nmsu
Member
 
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Feb 28, 2008 8:38 am


Return to Camp's Corner

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest