The vast majority of videos showing police using pepper spray show them using it at as a punishment rather than a "compliance tool". With all these new tools, tasers and the like, people are often not even given a chance to comply with any orders. Now these protesters were well warned but I think that since they showed no signs of active resistance, there should have been the attempt to physically remove them first. If the protesters had then actively fought with the officers I could see justification for using a more hands off approach to complience such as tasers or pepper spray.gigag04 wrote:"Compliance tools" are a loosing battle when it comes to 4th amendment seizures. You didnt listen to me so I'm going to Hurt you is just plain bad, and looks worse. I prefer a strategically placed hand or finger (google transport wrist lock or mandibular angle) for less violent and equally as effective methods to gain control.
Escalating up and down a use of force continuum with a violator is generally the appropriate response.
If you really want to see a way out of proportion response to a protest take a look at the anything from Pittsburg. I believe they got in trouble for their shirts that read "We get up early to beat the crowds".
My take on the video though...I think this officer actually behaved quite reasonably and professionally and is the victim of bad policy and sensationalized media.