Search found 9 matches

by seamusTX
Thu Jul 01, 2010 6:13 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

Re: A short memo to critics of the NRA

pbwalker wrote:... dismissing them is only doing a disservice....
I don't dismiss them. More power to them. They fill niches that the NRA does not.

However, a smarter man than I once said, "We must all hang together, or assuredly we shall all hang separately."

Or (not quoting anyone) shoot toward the enemy, not sideways and backward.

- Jim
by seamusTX
Thu Jul 01, 2010 4:35 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

Re: A short memo to critics of the NRA

That assumption is incorrect.

I'm confident that all the other three- and four-letter organizations, the Pink Pistols, etc., sincerely support the RKBA. So do many individuals who are not members of any organization.

What scorches my grits is when people who have done nothing significant criticize the NRA for not achieving enough. It reminds me of couch-potato sports fans (who would drop dead before completing a 1K run) who scream about a fumble or bad play.

- Jim
by seamusTX
Thu Jul 01, 2010 4:16 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

Re: A short memo to critics of the NRA

austinrealtor wrote:I'm all for sober, fact-driven, reasonable, unemotional discussion ... but its a two-way street. Even if confronted with a criticism of your organization that does not meet this standard, one should still respond in a way that DOES live up to this standard.
Given the volume of criticism of the NRA as "the gun lobby" and "wanting every 12-year-old to be able to bring a machine gun to school," this is an impossible task. It would be like swatting every mosquito in Texas in July.

You can't believe how much rhetoric of this sort has been generated by the McDonald decision until you look and listen.

And just with respect to the McDonald decision, everyone who is anti-RKBA give the NRA complete credit for this decision, while many of those within the pro-RKBA community diminish the role of the NRA.

I am addressing bona fide RKBA advocates who seem to be more concerned with ideological purity than results. They complain that the NRA has not achieved enough, or lately that the leadership has failed to abandon the interest of the membership for the sake of some abstract principle.

- Jim
by seamusTX
Thu Jul 01, 2010 3:56 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

Re: A short memo to critics of the NRA

Austinrealtor, I have several distinct concerns:

As I said earlier, the NRA has a proven track record. To achieve its goals, the NRA has had to lie down with dogs, wrestle with pigs, and otherwise get dirty. That is the nature of practical politics. It pains me to see the NRA leadership then criticized for not being ideologically pure enough.

This public criticism generally does not come from NRA members (though it might — Michael Moore is a life member of the NRA). Mostly it comes from people who are not members, never will be members, and run organizations that I consider self-serving (IMHO).

There is a much larger body of people who are not NRA members for a variety of reasons, including the notion that their name will get on some government list, the NRA sends too much junk mail, the NRA has its lips glued to the butt cheeks of politicians that they don't like, or the NRA doesn't endorse candidates that they do like.

These people do not hesitate to criticize the NRA; but somehow, I doubt the NRA leadership could ever satisfy them.

Finally, when RKBA proponents publicly criticize the NRA, this criticism is recycled by anti-RKBA interests in the form of "even NRA members disagree with X." Just look at the garbage on this link.

Everyone has a right to free speech. I don't deny that. But please think about what you say and know the possible consequences of saying it.

- Jim
by seamusTX
Tue Jun 29, 2010 9:27 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

Re: A short memo to critics of the NRA

On every issue, the NRA-ILA (we'll call it the NRA) can take exactly one public position. Is that clear? I don't mean to be condescending. The NRA can only advise legislators to vote for or against a bill, or an executive to sign or veto a bill.

The NRA's positions in Washington, D.C., and most state capitals have proven remarkably effective. We have no new federal "gun control" laws since (what?) 1994. The federal "assault weapons" ban is dead and buried. A congressional majority and administration that were anticipated to be hostile to the RKBA have been paralyzed in that regard. Legal carry in national parks is the law over the signature of Pres. Obama.

We have more shall-issue concealed-carry states, more places to carry, and more reciprocity. We have ironclad "castle doctrine" in more states. We have federal and state prohibitions on seizure of firearms in emergencies.

The NRA is not going to reflect the views of 4 million members precisely. The NRA's explanations of its actions are not going to satisfy 4 million members. Those are simply facts of life. I don't know of any organization or even family where everyone agrees about everything.

I'll say it again: I don't agree with NRA about everything. But I realize that it's the biggest and most effective RKBA organization, and I will continue to support it publicly and criticize it privately.

Cf. Ronald Reagan 11th commandment.

- Jim
by seamusTX
Tue Jun 29, 2010 5:27 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

Re: A short memo to critics of the NRA

Thank you.

Our enemies never give us a break. We don't need to help them.

- Jim
by seamusTX
Tue Jun 29, 2010 2:39 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

Re: A short memo to critics of the NRA

There's no need to apologize. I made an intentionally rude comment.

I'm getting tired of circular firing squads and foot perforations when there are plenty of more strategic targets.

- Jim
by seamusTX
Tue Jun 29, 2010 2:00 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

Re: A short memo to critics of the NRA

I'm not on the recruitment committee, and everybody has had years to come up with their rationalizations and excuses for keeping their checkbook closed.

It's not an aversion to critical thoughts. I have plenty of disagreements with the NRA.

My hot point is when people complain that the NRA is not sufficiently politically correct, or even start attributing secret nefarious motives to the NRA leadership.

Politics is an ugly business. Sometimes winning ugly is the only way to win.

- Jim
by seamusTX
Tue Jun 29, 2010 1:09 pm
Forum: National Rifle Association
Topic: A short memo to critics of the NRA
Replies: 30
Views: 6050

A short memo to critics of the NRA

hoof.jpg
Start your own 4-million-member organization or deal with reality.

Respectfully,

- Jim

Return to “A short memo to critics of the NRA”