I think that most people can't comprehend why the courts have allowed the fourth amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures to morph from warrants issued for "probable cause" to searches requiring only "reasonable suspicion".mojo84 wrote:This supports my comment in another thread. The laws are so complicated even cops disagree on the them. I think it was in a thread that was talking about 30.06.jbarn wrote:That is actually not correct. Reasonable suspicion is all that is needed.texanjoker wrote:Real cops eat bagels03Lightningrocks wrote:I am willing to bet that most cops pull someone over because something about that person or the driving gave them reason to sniff around. I have trouble believing a cop is going to quit eating his or her donut to pull over a car because the color of the car is green instead of purple......One needs some sort of PC to make a stop
Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
Moderators: carlson1, Charles L. Cotton
- WildBill
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17350
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2007 12:53 pm
- Location: Houston
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
NRA Endowment Member
- gigag04
- Senior Member
- Posts: 5474
- Joined: Wed May 04, 2005 7:47 pm
- Location: Houston
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
You can stop with RS that the driver is drunk or an occupant has warrants.
Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work. - Thomas Edison
- mojo84
- Senior Member
- Posts: 9045
- Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2011 4:07 pm
- Location: Boerne, TX (Kendall County)
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
This seems so basic I can't understand how cops cannot agree.
Here's the post from the other thread.
Here's the post from the other thread.
I say the same thing about cops when they are supposed to be the professionals enforcing the laws and protecting the rights of citizens. Especially when we are talking about the basics and not some esoteric law that rarely comes into play.texanjoker wrote:Hard to not agree to a point. A business owner shouldn't have to play the guessing game if he wants to ban guns from his business. The way the current system is set up, even people in this forum post about signs and whether they are valid. If we are going to have these types of signs, knowing if they are valid or not should be simple.
Note: Me sharing a link and information published by others does not constitute my endorsement, agreement, disagreement, my opinion or publishing by me. If you do not like what is contained at a link I share, take it up with the author or publisher of the content.
- Oldgringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 11203
- Joined: Sat Mar 08, 2008 10:15 pm
- Location: Pineywoods of east Texas
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
Yes. As someone said earlier, there will always be a reason for the stop.
-
Dave2
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3167
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2010 1:39 am
- Location: Bay Area, CA
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
VoiceofReason wrote:I will tell one on myself.
I was going East on highway XX and a car blew by me going West. I made a U-turn and punched it. He saw me make the turn and slowed down, so I was just a few car lengths behind him in five or ten seconds.
It was early morning with very little traffic and I did not turn my overheads on while checking the plate number. It came back OK so I just stayed about ten car lengths behind him. He slowed way down and I slowed way down. He pulled over on the shoulder for me to pass and I just stayed about ten car lengths behind him so he moved back into the lane. I followed him about ten miles without turning on my overheads and by this time he was so hinky he didn’t know what to do.![]()
I figured he was “sweating bullets” by now and I had made my point. I made another U-turn and headed back east figuring this guy had learned a lesson without me even stopping him. I would like to have heard the names he called me.
I am not a lawyer, nor have I played one on TV, nor did I stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night, nor should anything I say be taken as legal advice. If it is important that any information be accurate, do not use me as the only source.
-
JSThane
- Banned
- Posts: 610
- Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2011 12:07 pm
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
I had a Kansas cop do that to me on a road trip, except I was traveling exactly at the speed limit. He followed my Mustang until I left his county, waiting for me to touch that accelerator (red Mustang, out of state plates, equals big sign saying "mess with this guy!"). I didn't, but neither did I touch the brake.VoiceofReason wrote:I will tell one on myself.
I was going East on highway XX and a car blew by me going West. I made a U-turn and punched it. He saw me make the turn and slowed down, so I was just a few car lengths behind him in five or ten seconds.
It was early morning with very little traffic and I did not turn my overheads on while checking the plate number. It came back OK so I just stayed about ten car lengths behind him. He slowed way down and I slowed way down. He pulled over on the shoulder for me to pass and I just stayed about ten car lengths behind him so he moved back into the lane. I followed him about ten miles without turning on my overheads and by this time he was so hinky he didn’t know what to do.![]()
I figured he was “sweating bullets” by now and I had made my point. I made another U-turn and headed back east figuring this guy had learned a lesson without me even stopping him. I would like to have heard the names he called me.
I think he was frustrated that I never did, but I saw his under-grill lights when he passed me in the opposite direction, before he turned around.
- WildBill
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17350
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2007 12:53 pm
- Location: Houston
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
As someone said earlier, probable cause, reasonable suspicion, "what does it matter?"Oldgringo wrote:Yes. As someone said earlier, there will always be a reason for the stop.
NRA Endowment Member
- Oldgringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 11203
- Joined: Sat Mar 08, 2008 10:15 pm
- Location: Pineywoods of east Texas
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
Exactly! Being pulled over is one thing, being charged/ticketed/jailed is a horse of an entirely different color.WildBill wrote:As someone said earlier, probable cause, reasonable suspicion, "what does it matter?"Oldgringo wrote:Yes. As someone said earlier, there will always be a reason for the stop.
- mojo84
- Senior Member
- Posts: 9045
- Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2011 4:07 pm
- Location: Boerne, TX (Kendall County)
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
Show me your papers comrade. 
Note: Me sharing a link and information published by others does not constitute my endorsement, agreement, disagreement, my opinion or publishing by me. If you do not like what is contained at a link I share, take it up with the author or publisher of the content.
-
texanjoker
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
Best PC is a person smoking that speeds past your patrol car thinking you can't stop them. When you light them up (turn on the police lights) the person then flicks their lit cigarette off your patrol car windshield laughing03Lightningrocks wrote:I am thinking the officer would then wait to see if the driver was in possession of canned iced tea.WildBill wrote:So you wouldn't pull over a car if the driver was eating a bagel? What about if he was munching on some Skittles?texanjoker wrote:Real cops eat bagels.....One needs some sort of PC to make a stop.
. You forgot, this officer is looking for two PC's.
- Jumping Frog
- Senior Member
- Posts: 5488
- Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 9:13 am
- Location: Klein, TX (Houston NW suburb)
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
Regardless of whether the stop is based on reasonable suspicion, probable cause, or "driving while <insert any reason here>", I'll also point out that one doesn't argue the legal reason for the stop with a cop on the side of the road. One argues the question in front of a judge. In a criminal case, at a suppression hearing. In a civil case, at a deposition.
As a young man, one other piece of wisdom passed onto me was about being courteous to police officers. I was advised that, while I may have the right to make a telephone call, the arresting officer gets to decide whether I make that call from the police station or from the emergency room.

As a young man, one other piece of wisdom passed onto me was about being courteous to police officers. I was advised that, while I may have the right to make a telephone call, the arresting officer gets to decide whether I make that call from the police station or from the emergency room.
-Just call me Bob . . . Texas Firearms Coalition, NRA Life member, TSRA Life member, and OFCC Patron member
This froggie ain't boiling! Shall not be infringed! Μολών Λαβέ
This froggie ain't boiling! Shall not be infringed! Μολών Λαβέ
- 03Lightningrocks
- Senior Member
- Posts: 11461
- Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 5:15 pm
- Location: Plano
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
Jumping Frog wrote:Regardless of whether the stop is based on reasonable suspicion, probable cause, or "driving while <insert any reason here>", I'll also point out that one doesn't argue the legal reason for the stop with a cop on the side of the road. One argues the question in front of a judge. In a criminal case, at a suppression hearing. In a civil case, at a deposition.
As a young man, one other piece of wisdom passed onto me was about being courteous to police officers. I was advised that, while I may have the right to make a telephone call, the arresting officer gets to decide whether I make that call from the police station or from the emergency room.![]()
I did learn as a teen that cops have no desire to play roadside courtroom with us. There is usually no gain to be had from arguing with a cop about the intricacies of his right to pull you over while sitting on the side of the road. That is what courts are for.
NRA-Endowment Member
http://www.planoair.com
http://www.planoairconditioningandheating.com
http://www.planoair.com
http://www.planoairconditioningandheating.com
- WildBill
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17350
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2007 12:53 pm
- Location: Houston
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
There is a scene in the movie "The New Centurions" where, after pulling over a BG, the senior officer tells his partner to call for an ambulance. The BG says "Why, there's nobody hurt! The officer tells him, if you don't get in the car there will be.03Lightningrocks wrote:Jumping Frog wrote:Regardless of whether the stop is based on reasonable suspicion, probable cause, or "driving while <insert any reason here>", I'll also point out that one doesn't argue the legal reason for the stop with a cop on the side of the road. One argues the question in front of a judge. In a criminal case, at a suppression hearing. In a civil case, at a deposition.
As a young man, one other piece of wisdom passed onto me was about being courteous to police officers. I was advised that, while I may have the right to make a telephone call, the arresting officer gets to decide whether I make that call from the police station or from the emergency room.![]()
I don't think I ever heard it put that way. Police station or emergency room...
![]()
I did learn as a teen that cops have no desire to play roadside courtroom with us. There is usually no gain to be had from arguing with a cop about the intricacies of his right to pull you over while sitting on the side of the road. That is what courts are for.
NRA Endowment Member
- mojo84
- Senior Member
- Posts: 9045
- Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2011 4:07 pm
- Location: Boerne, TX (Kendall County)
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
The good old days of street side justice.
Note: Me sharing a link and information published by others does not constitute my endorsement, agreement, disagreement, my opinion or publishing by me. If you do not like what is contained at a link I share, take it up with the author or publisher of the content.
- 03Lightningrocks
- Senior Member
- Posts: 11461
- Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 5:15 pm
- Location: Plano
Re: Can police pull you over with no probable cause?
Wildbill, that was some funny stuff! 
NRA-Endowment Member
http://www.planoair.com
http://www.planoairconditioningandheating.com
http://www.planoair.com
http://www.planoairconditioningandheating.com