TexasCHLforum.com

anygunanywhere wrote:
I carry a really sharp knife all of the time.

If it was me, one agaisnt four, I doubt I would pull a knife that the four could take away from me and carve my carcass.

I stand by my post.

I would not have exited my vehicle if I saw four bangers exit a vehicle that just rear-ended me. I drive a Ford F250 Superduty diesel. Loaded down with my tools etc it goes almost 7000 lbs.

I use my truck as a weapon. I doubt a rice burning banger mobile and four bangers would handle the truck.

Herb, I have thought about these scenarios and in this one pulling a knife was not the answer. If it was for you great. Go for it. IMHO the knife suggestion was not the right one.

Anygunanywhere but probably not a knife.

I don't think anyone recommended exiting the vehicle, and it is good advice you give to avoid doing this (in most cases). Using the truck is good too.

No one suggested "pulling a knife" nor certainly not letting them take it from you -- but as you and I both have it (I have two) they would end up with meeting the knives before I let the four gang bang me or my family.

Although I would definitely be in fear of my life and great bodily harm, two knives (along with a wee bit of skill with them) and the pepper spray would likely make it an interesting fight, as long as they don't have firearms, if they insisted.

Knife techniques are worth some study. It is actually pretty difficult to even grab or punch a person who knows how to HOLD a knife.

kyreb wrote:I was interviewed this morning. These guys are Ex-LEO and one Ex-Delta, very pro gun and pro CHL. Turns out they have been urging Legal to exempt CHL's from the policy with little to no success. They are developing a database of close calls employees experience to build their case. They loved the last paragraph I added.

Hmmm...well...I wouldn't stoop to advising you to waste a pound of Bullseye "salting" the parking area just before the next dog search...would I?

HerbM wrote:I don't think anyone recommended exiting the vehicle, and it is good advice you give to avoid doing this (in most cases).

If you can (and do) move the vehicle well out of the roadway, then staying in it is a good idea, but otherwise, do you want to be inside it unable to dodge quickly if somebody else slams into the existing accident?

HerbM wrote:

anygunanywhere wrote:
I carry a really sharp knife all of the time.

If it was me, one agaisnt four, I doubt I would pull a knife that the four could take away from me and carve my carcass.

I stand by my post.

I would not have exited my vehicle if I saw four bangers exit a vehicle that just rear-ended me. I drive a Ford F250 Superduty diesel. Loaded down with my tools etc it goes almost 7000 lbs.

I use my truck as a weapon. I doubt a rice burning banger mobile and four bangers would handle the truck.

Herb, I have thought about these scenarios and in this one pulling a knife was not the answer. If it was for you great. Go for it. IMHO the knife suggestion was not the right one.

Anygunanywhere but probably not a knife.

I don't think anyone recommended exiting the vehicle, and it is good advice you give to avoid doing this (in most cases). Using the truck is good too.

No one suggested "pulling a knife" nor certainly not letting them take it from you -- but as you and I both have it (I have two) they would end up with meeting the knives before I let the four gang bang me or my family.

Although I would definitely be in fear of my life and great bodily harm, two knives (along with a wee bit of skill with them) and the pepper spray would likely make it an interesting fight, as long as they don't have firearms, if they insisted.

Knife techniques are worth some study. It is actually pretty difficult to even grab or punch a person who knows how to HOLD a knife.

Agreed!

Any type of weapon (vs. fists/feet) might allow you to maintain distance or retreat to a safer position to summons help.

I have a little bit of knife training...and I can honestly say... I would be loathe to try to disarm/attack someone (even an unskilled person) who was waving an edged weapon and showing any amount of determination.

Of course, common sense tells us not to deploy/reveal the weapon until absolutely necessary, for a variety of reasons.

Depending upon where I plan to go in a day...I may or may not have my 1911 on my person (I don't carry 24/7). But....I ALWAYS have my knife (thanks El Gato).

HerbM wrote: No one suggested "pulling a knife" nor certainly not letting them take it from you -- but as you and I both have it (I have two) they would end up with meeting the knives before I let the four gang bang me or my family.

When someone asks for critique and someone alse suggests a knife I make the connection that it is suggested for self defense. You have to pull the knife for self defense.

Anygunanywhere

I always carry a knife too. But I would much rather have a baseball bat, tire iron, cane or staff if faced with four gangbangers with knives. The more distance I can create the less likelihood I will be cut. If I use the knife, I will get cut. With a bat, cane or staff, I might get out of it without cuts. But in the end, you use whatever weapon you have a hand to survive.

anygunanywhere wrote:

HerbM wrote: No one suggested "pulling a knife" nor certainly not letting them take it from you -- but as you and I both have it (I have two) they would end up with meeting the knives before I let the four gang bang me or my family.

When someone asks for critique and someone alse suggests a knife I make the connection that it is suggested for self defense. You have to pull the knife for self defense.

Anygunanywhere

Not really -- many times using a knife surrepticously, which isn't implied by "pull a knife", is the best method. Secreting the knife in your hand such that if you are grabbed the attacker is automatically cut has a range of uses.

One of the most difficult positions to "take away" a knife is the "reverse hold, lying along the forearm, blade out" method. The knife is largely hidden, and it is also quite a bit harder to cut your self (though not impossible) when using this method.

You only use it or show it once you are UNDER ATTACK -- at which point I am in fear of my life and getting cut with my own knife is the least of my worries.

DoubleJ wrote:

kyreb wrote:I am thinking of starting to park in the randall's grocery store lot a few blocks from my building. Wonder how long before my truck would get towed?

or worse, broken into, and then have the one thing you'd wanna hang on to stolen, as well.

Depends on the safety of the area. I have a relative inexpensive gun safe that fits under the seat of my car. It is secured with a cable around the seat post. Won't stop some one with cable cutters but will keep you safe from a smash and grab type car theif.

Which Galleria Mall, may I ask? Dallas? Glad you're OK.

KC5AV wrote:I doubt a taser would do much good in a 4 on 1 fight.

agreed, especially when you consider the 4 were highly strung out

kyreb wrote: Oh, I was telling 911 all about the fight and the knife. Did not help the response time one bit. The first responder told me the dispatcher had incorrectly advised the units I was being attacked rather than the bangers mixing it up. I would have been long dead had that been the case.

First responder thought you were being attacked and it still took 20 minutes to get there? Really gives you a sense of confidence.

When seconds count help is only twenty minutes away!

Anygunanywhere